An age-old debate among educators, students, and parents revolves around the question, “How much homework is too much?” If you have a child in school, then you know that their answer is “any homework” is too much. Research on this topic offers compelling evidence for both sides of this debate. On one side, homework can reinforce learning and improve students’ grades; on the other, homework can be stressful and negatively impact students’ mental health. Here, we’ll take a closer look at both sides of the argument, as well as explore how you can find the right balance.
The Impact of Homework
While homework has always been a controversial debate, it’s also been a staple in many classrooms. It’s designed to reinforce what students are learning in the classroom. Proponents of homework say it can help students develop good study habits, give them a sense of responsibility, and give their parents an idea of what their child is learning.
Past research has shown that middle school and high school students who do homework do better on standardized tests. Homework can also help students develop essential skills such as critical thinking, problem-solving, and self-discipline, all of which they can use throughout their lives. Additionally, it can boost self-esteem, which enables students to understand how to manage their time efficiently.
Students Mental Health
The potential downsides of too much homework can have a negative impact on student mental health says research from Stanford University. The study showed that students who spent too much time on homework felt more stressed, experienced more physical health problems such as headaches, sleep deprivation, and weight loss, and felt they had a hard time balancing their lives outside of the classroom. They also suggested that any more than two hours of homework per night would be counterproductive. Some mental health experts agree, saying a heavy workload can indeed do more harm than good.
Finding the Right Balance
As mentioned earlier, research has shown that one of the downsides of too much homework is that students have a hard time balancing homework and their social lives. The key is to strike a balance between both.
Follow Guidelines
For homework to have a positive impact on students, then you must follow grade-specific guidelines. The National Education Association and the National PTA recommend the “ten-minute rule.” This rule suggests ten minutes of homework per grade level. So, first graders would have ten minutes of homework per night, while sixth graders would have one hour, and twelfth graders would have two hours. While not everyone agrees with this recommendation, it is a general guideline recommended by experts and used by many school districts. Ultimately, it is up to you, as the teacher or your administrator, if they have specific rules for you to follow.
Create Purposeful Assignments
The quality of homework assignments matters. According to authors from the Stanford study, homework should have a purpose. Assignments that align with what students are learning can be more effective. When giving homework, think about quality or quantity. Ask yourself, “Is the assignment meaningful?” Design homework that stimulates thinking without overwhelming students. For older students, remember your class isn’t the only class they are taking.
Consider Individual Needs
Just as there is no one-size-fits-all answer to the question of “How much is too much homework”, it’s important to recognize there is also no one-size-fits-all approach regarding students’ individual needs. Each student has different learning styles and abilities, and recognizing this diversity will help you accommodate each student, so they are successful and efficient at completing their homework. Being flexible with each students’ unique circumstance will help them be able to strike a balance between their homework and their lives.
Other Factors to Consider
When assessing the amount of homework you should assign, a few other factors to consider include the role parents may play and the resources available to them at home. These factors are essential in helping you develop your homework strategy.
Parental Involvement
Parents play an important role in their child’s education. Their guidance and support can have a significant impact on the effectiveness of a student’s homework. However, parental involvement may vary. Overly involved parents may hinder students from mastering their skills by doing their homework for them, whereas less engaged parents may not be home to offer help or not offer help to a child who needs it. This variety in parental involvement shows how important it is to strike a balanced approach to homework.
Access to Resources
In this digital age, it may be hard to fathom that not all children will have access to resources at home such as the internet, however, these are the unfortunate facts. While the percentage may be low, ethnicity and income do play a part in those who have access to resources such as internet connectivity. To ensure that homework serves a purpose and is not a barrier, keep in mind students’ availability of resources when thinking about the amount of homework you are assigning.
There is no right or wrong answer to the question, “How much homework is too much?” It depends on many factors, such as academic performance, mental health, students’ ability to balance their lives, and their access to available resources. As the quest for answers continues, it’s important to foster homework practices that align with a purpose and are tailored to the needs of your students. Keep in mind that most adults don’t come home after a full day at work and then work for another two to three hours, so your students should not have to either.
Educators never stop learning; check out our available graduate degree programs to hone your skills and promote lifelong learning and academic excellence.
